In my post earlier this week, I shared some journal articles from the UK printing industry on the subject of the new FSC Online Claims Platform (OCP). They were of interest to me because they echoed much of the quiet grumbling that I have been hearing from FSC participants throughout North America. This morning, I learned of some much more focused and specific feedback to FSC on this subject – provided in this case from two paper industry trade groups, the Confederation of Paper Industries (CPI) and the Confederation of European Paper Industries (CEPI). Please give them a read:
I found these letters to be quite compelling and important for several reasons. First of all, this is the first example that I have seen of a prominent FSC stakeholder specifically asking FSC to halt the implementation of the OCP. Secondly, and probably more important, I am impressed by the articulate way in which Ms. Presas and Mr. Workman make their central case. They oppose the OCP implementation not because it will be bad for business (which it probably will), but rather because it most probably will be bad for FSC. And that would be a real shame.
Yes. Naturally the OCP is completely unpractical. I am at a loss how small forest owners with limited internet access will comply. Also the scope exists for African countries to move forward with FSC FM. Having worked in africa it is clear that internet access is sporadic and this presents a barrier for those that do not have technology and this economically selects against. Possibly one of the most counterintuitive measures taken by FSC for a long time (another paradox / odd scenario like creating FSC CW). Completely out of touch.
Your comment about Africa is interesting to me. I see rather little feedback from the developing world and often wonder how FSC-IC managed to maintain its intended focus to the south.
It has been suggested to me that the OCP initiative is rooted in misgiving over the rapid growth of CoC certification in China. I have hopes of doing some research on this topic at some point. If anyone with experience there or suggestions for sources, I would be grateful for the help.